| 2021-2022 | |
| Grace Colvin | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Hannah Chaney | University of the Cumberlands |
| Mikayla Jolly | University of Evansville |
| Kellene Engelhart | Illinois College |
| Lily Garbett | Illinois College |
| Alivia Conte | University of South Dakota |
| 2020-2021 | |
| Katie Smith | Southern Illinois University @ Edwardsville |
| Lexi Garloch | Hanover University |
| Nora Patton | Indiana University Southeast |
| Lyndsi Adamson | Indiana State University |
| 2019-2020 | |
| Lindsey Bangert | Millikin University |
| Kaitlynn Bennett | Anderson University |
| Madison Duncan | Columbus State/Southern Indiana |
| 2018-2019 | |
| Madison Scott | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Kyndell Ethridge | Fort Wayne |
| Mariah Clark | Cumberland College |
| Kenedy Harris | Freed Hardiman |
| 2017-2018 | |
| Jade Montgomery | Eastern Illinois |
| Megan Eder | Southern Indiana/Charleston University |
| Destinee Miles | Charleston University |
| Hannah Shirley | Francis Marion/Unviersity of Evansville |
| Alexis Smith | Eastern Illinois |
| 2016-2017 | |
| Natalie David | Coastal Carolina |
| Lacey Wilzbacher | Fort Wayne |
| 2015-2016 | |
| Bridget Pepper | Franklin University |
| Kenedy House | Charleston University |
| Megan Godoyo | Southern Arkansas University |
| Katilin Kralj | Cumberland University |
| Chelsea Gordon | Morthland |
| Rachel Friesner | Robert Morris @ Springfield |
| 2014-2015 | |
| Allison Webster | Carson Newman |
| Kennedy Christy | North Alabama |
| Carley Childress | Akron |
| Kera Hartman | Point University |
| 2013-2014 | |
| Kalyn Chapman | University of West Florida |
| Brooke Childress | University of Evansville |
| Bailey Gilbert | Oakland City University |
| Megan Klees | Oakland City University |
| Amanda Gilliland | Spalding University |
| Samantha Marksbury | Kentucky Wesleyan University |
| Cortney Norris | University of Charleston |
| 2012-2013 | |
| Abbi Fahse | University of Evansville |
| Sarah Burnham | Saint Marys of the Woods |
| Kirby Schuble | Saint Marys of the Woods |
| Amanda Trampe | Lindsey Wilson |
| 2011-2012 | |
| Amber Schedelbower | Millikin University |
| Macy Toon | St. Mary's of the Woods |
| 2010-2011 | |
| Ashton Morgan | Trine University |
| Brooke Owens | Eastern Illinois |
| Kelsi Reed | Cleveland State University |
| Natasha Chapman | College of Saint Marys |
| Melanie Brown | University of Southern Indiana |
| 2009-2010 | |
| Emily Priar | Lindsey Wilson |
| Hannah Croucher | IUPUI |
| Kat Tennis | Univ of Missouri @ St. Louis |
| Kayla Meny | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Jordan Vertz | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Katy Kruse | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Jackie Porter | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| 2008-2009 | |
| Kristen Broadway | Murray State University |
| Taylor Wilson | Murray State University |
| Brooke McCartney | Morehead State University |
| LeAnn Collins | Southern Indiana |
| Emerald Graham | Elon University |
| Amy Orender | Southern University |
| 2007-2008 | |
| Falon DeVore | Oakland City University |
| Ashley Eberhard | Kentucky Wesleyan University |
| Leah Emerick | Kentucky Wesleyan University |
| Megan Shadrick | Belmont University |
| Amanda Maurer | College of Charleston |
| Carrie Wilderman | Asbury College (KY) |
| 2006-2007 | |
| Amanda Mackey | IUPUI |
| Kelly Ottis | Augustana (S.D.) |
| Tiffany Ferguson | Oakland City University |
| Laura Wuebbels | Lindenwood University |
| Brittany Ferguson | Oakland City University |
| 2005-2006 | |
| Kirsten Morgan | University of Southern Indiana |
| Courtney Bates | University of Southern Indiana |
| Cassie Turley | Union University |
| Niki Stewart | Northern Kentucky University |
| Ashley Tharp | Indiana - Purdue @ Fort Wayne |
| Michelle Reyher | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2004-2005 | |
| Sabra McCune | Southern Illinois University- Edwardsville |
| Allie May | Indiana State University |
| Andrea Bailey | IUPUI |
| Nicole Keith | Webster University |
| 2003-2004 | |
| Angie Davis | University of Southern Indiana |
| Kelli Pitts | University of North Florida |
| Tracy Reyland | Lincoln University |
| Ashlee Maurer | Missouri Baptist |
| Bradi Johnson | Missouri Baptist |
| 2002-2003 | |
| Amy Fahnestock | Southeast Missouri University |
| Ashley Demarest | Troy State University |
| Stephanie Ellis | St. Mary's of the Woods |
| Nickole Henson | University of Southern Indiana |
| Ashley Alka | Mid- Continent |
| 2001-2002 | |
| Shannon Emmons | University of Southern Indiana |
| Nichole Pike | University of Southern Indiana |
| Angie Huebner | Tennessee State (Middle Tennessee State) |
| Rachel Emmons | Oakland City University |
| 2000-2001 | |
| Holly Shook | Kentucky Wesleyan (Mid-Continent) |
| Melissa Smith | Ekard College (FL) |
| Sara Kothe | Indiana State |
| Lauren Gidcumb | Olivet Nazarene |
| Angie Davis | Cumberland College (KY) |
| Leanna Myers | Oakland City University |
| 1999-2000 | |
| Leah Barnes | Florida International |
| Tina Owens | University of Missouri- St. Louis |
| Elaine Hurt | University of Southern Indiana |
| Danielle Garnett | University of Southern Indiana |
| Tiffany Thomas | Brewton-Parker (GA) |
| 1998-1999 | |
| Ashley Tooley | University of Missouri-St. Louis |
| Sara Beck | Southeast Missouri University |
| Allison Maurer | University of Missouri- St. Louis |
| Jonnel Reitman | Southeast Missouri University |
| Brannon Brumley | Mideast University |
| 1997-1998 | |
| Brooke Kinder | Oakland City University |
| Leslie Kolle | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Julie Burton | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| 1996-1997 | |
| Megan Widowski | Cumberland College (KY) |
| Leann Giriden | Brescia College (KY) |
| Danielle Lamberson | Ohio University |
| Sara Downey | University of Missouri- St. Louis |
| 1995-1996 | |
| Michelle Russell | Oakland City University |
| Melissa Russell | Oakland City University |
| Amanda Elmendorf | College of Charleston (SC) |
| Brenda Haus | University of Southern Colorado |
| 1994-1995 | |
| Betsy Vetter | Francis Marion University (GA) |
| Stacy Stewart | Francis Marion University (GA) |
| Jennifer Zaeske | Coastal Carolina University |
| Tara Black | University of West Georgia |
| Lisa Diehl | Akron University |