| NJCAA All American | ||
| Tonya Lindsey | 2nd Team | 1982 |
| Melinda Barton | 1st Team | 1985 |
| Melinda Barton | 1st Team | 1986 |
| Beth Goodwin | 2nd Team | 1987 |
| Jennifer Bradley | 1st Team | 1989 |
| Gloria Marcoft | 3rd Team | 1991 |
| Maureen Morris | 3rd Team | 1997 |
| Tara Hatfield | 1st Team | 2000 |
| Megan Widowski | 3rd Team | 1997 |
| Sarah Beck | 3rd Team | 1998 |
| Brannon Brumley | 3rd Team | 1998 |
| Miranda Glover | 3rd Team | 2001 |
| Nichole Pike | 3rd Team | 2001 |
| Nichole Pike | 1st Team | 2003 |
| Ashley Demarest | 3rd Team | 2005 |
| Sabra McCune | 1st Team | 2004 |
| Vicki Gates | 2nd Team | 2004 |
| Sabra McCune | 1st Team | 2005 |
| Kirsten Morgan | 2nd Team | 2008 |
| Cassie Turley | 3rd Team | 2008 |
| Kristen Broadway | 2nd Team | 2008 |
| Megan Shadrick | 2nd Team | 2009 |
| Emerald Graham | 3rd Team | 2008 |
| Kristen Broadway | 1st Team | 2009 |
| LeAnn Collins | 2nd Team | 2009 |
| Amanda Trampe | 3rd Team | 2012 |
| Abbi Fahse | 3rd Team | 2013 |
| Cortney Norris | 3rd Team | 2014 |
| Kalyn Chapman | 2nd Team | 2014 |
| Allison Webster | 3rd Team | 2015 |
| Bailey Winters | 3rd Team | 2016 |
| Natalie David | 3rd Team | 2017 |
| Destinee Miles | 2nd Team | 2018 |
| Jade Montgomery | 3rd Team | 2018 |
| Paige Byrd | 3rd Team | 2018 |
| Academic All Americans | |
| Sara Vogt | 2000 |
| Erin Spencer | 2000 |
| Stephanie Ellis | 2003 |
| Bradi Johnson | 2004 |
| Ashlee Maurer | 2004 |
| Erin Detty | 2004 |
| Danielle Walls | 2004 |
| Andrea Bailey | 2005 |
| Allie May | 2005 |
| Michelle Reyher | 2006 |
| Kelly Beattie | 2007 |
| Alyssa Hoffman | 2007 |
| Hillary Pollard | 2007 |
| Emily Westhus | 2007 |
| Laura Wuebbels | 2007 |
| Falon Devore | 2008 |
| Kristen Broadway | 2009 |
| Taylor Wilson | 2009 |
| Jacki Porter | 2010 |
| Mary Tindle | 2010 |
| Emily Priar | 2010 |
| Hannah Croucher | 2010 |
| Katherine Tennis | 2010 |
| Ashton Morgan | 2011 |
| Brooke Owens | 2011 |
| Jaimie Stutsman | 2011 |
| Hayley Wilson | 2011 |
| Lauren Martin | 2012 |
| Megan Darr | 2012 |
| Macy Toon | 2012 |
| Alisha Lowery | 2012 |
| Amanda Trampe | 2013 |
| Ariel Hurt | 2013 |
| Hannah Frederick | 2013 |
| Jessie Seiler | 2013 |
| Andrea Miller | 2013 |
| Samantha Saltzman | 2013 |
| Megan Klees | 2014 |
| Allison Webster | 2015 |
| Joie Gadberry | 2015 |
| Kendal Mendenhall | 2015 |
| Bailey Winters | 2016 |
| Kaitlin Kralj | 2016 |
| Keagan Helson | 2016 |
| Kenedy House | 2016 |
| Lacey Wilzbacher | 2016 |
| Mallory Rutz | 2016 |
| Megan Godoyo | 2016 |
| Natalie David | 2016 |
| Andrea Powell | 2017 |
| Kaitlyn Woodward | 2017 |
| Mallory Rutz | 2017 |
| Alexis Smith | 2017 |
| Destinee Miles | 2017 |
| Jade Montgomery | 2017 |
| Taylor Miles | 2017 |
| Megan Eder | 2017 |
| Natalie David | 2017 |
| Destinee Miles | 2018 |
| Emma Robinson | 2018 |
| Haley Shewmake | 2018 |
| Jade Montgomery | 2018 |
| Kyndell Ethridge | 2018 |
| Madison Bauer | 2018 |
| Megan Eder | 2018 |
| Morgan Combs | 2018 |
| Paige Byrd | 2018 |
| Taylor Miles | 2018 |
| Caroline Campbell | 2019 |
| Haley Shewmake | 2019 |
| Kaitlynn Bennett | 2019 |
| Kennedy Harris | 2019 |
| Lindsey Bangert | 2019 |
| Maci Simmons | 2019 |
| Madison Bauer | 2019 |
| Madison Scott | 2019 |
| Paige Byrd | 2019 |
| Skyler Freeman | 2019 |
| Sydni Cosby | 2019 |
| Lyndsi Adamson | 2020 |
| Lindsey Bangert | 2020 |
| Ella Banks | 2020 |
| Kaitlynn Bennett | 2020 |
| Kendall Beyerle | 2020 |
| Sydni Cosby | 2020 |
| Sophie Heck | 2020 |
| Gracey Himelick | 2020 |
| Morgan Moxey | 2020 |
| Casey Schweitzer | 2020 |
| Lexi Garloch | 2020 |
| Maci Simmons | 2020 |
| Katie Smith | 2020 |
| Kelsey Stanton | 2020 |
| Brooke Wilhite | 2020 |
| Sophie Heck | 2021 |
| Gracey Himelick | 2021 |
| Lyndsi Adamson | 2021 |
| Lainie Milner | 2021 |
| Regan Bell | 2021 |
| Kellene Engelhart | 2021 |
| Lily Garbett | 2021 |
| Casey Schweitzer | 2021 |
| Katherine Smith | 2021 |
| Malena Bixby | 2021 |
| Malena Bixby | 2022 |
| Alivia Conte | 2022 |
| Kellene Engelhart | 2022 |
| Lily Garbett | 2022 |
| Adleen Nolley | 2022 |
| Lexi Renner | 2022 |
| Braley Roberts | 2022 |
| Hannah Chaney | 2022 |
| Kinely Edwards | 2022 |
| Maggie O'Kelley | 2022 |
| Casey Schweitzer | 2022 |
Team Academic Awards
| 2001 | 1st in NJCAA Softball Nationally** |
| 2004 | 7th in NJCAA Softball Nationally |
| 2007 | 5th in NJCAA Softball Nationally |
| 2008 | 5th in NJCAA Softball Nationally |
| 2010 | 5th in NJCAA Softball Nationally |
| 2011 | 3rd in NJCAA Softball Nationally |
| 2012 | 1st in NJCAA Softball Nationally** |
| 2019 | 5th in NJCAA Softball Nationally |
| 2020 | 1st in NJCAA Softball Nationally** |
| ** National Academic Team of the Year |